We've stayed at AKV, BWV, BCV, VWL, and SSR (haven't tried BLT, OKW, or any of the non WDW resorts.) We've liked all the ones we've stayed at so far, and would stay at any of them again. We also love the GF, and were delighted when they announced GFV, and we plan to buy there.
For me
BCV
BWV
AKV
VWL
big gap, and then SSR. I don't hate it, I'm willing to stay there, and I find things to like about it when we're there
For DH
BWV
AKV
VWL
BCV
SSR
Honestly, he's almost equally happy with any of the resorts. He really likes BLT (we've visited friends' rooms), but we haven't had luck booking it at the 7 month point so far. We were considering buying points there, but I am not a fan of the decor, and the reports we've heard of rooms not wearing well have made us nervous. We were both glad when GFV were announced, and that will be the MK resort we purchase.
How DS (age 6) would answer this -
AKV
AKV - no, I really want to go to AKV
AKV - why can't we stay at AKV?
AKV - but it's my favorite, can we at least go visit?
BCV - Stormalong Bay is cool
VWL - it's sort of like AKV, but without the animals
BWV -the boardwalk entertainers are fun, but do we really have to walk to DHS again?
SSR - only if we can walk to the
Lego store and TRex