My vote is for VGF (we own there). I like the Poly main lobby, restaurants and bars but hated the difficulty booking any restaurant at the Poly. I didn't love the Poly rooms when we stayed there and we were very far from the main lobby/monorail. We found the main pool to be overcrowded and hectic and the quiet pool to be a bit boring. At VGF, we really like both pools, the covered walkway to the Villas (we were once completely drenched going back to our room at Poly), and the multiple restaurants we can book. It's only a 4-5 min walk to the Poly so we easily walk over for Dole Whips or shopping. We also prefer a 1 or 2 bedroom and never stay in studios anymore with 3 kids. Both are beautiful so you will probably be fine with either option but once you've stayed in a 1 bedroom, you'll buy more points....