We stayed here in October and it was wonderful. to those who remember staying here and everything was small...are you sure it was the same hotel there are SO many with similar names. This one used to be TRAIN themed.
They were starting the nick overhaul when we were there. And because of the constuction we got a rate of $129 including breakfast. Breakfast was tolerable but not great. Same for the food court.
The things that worked for us.
1. The Room. A full size king bedroom with closet, desk, drawer space, ceiling fan and a DOOR
! A kid room with bunk bed and a pull-out bed (plus a table and video game console) A small but adequate suite room with fridge and table. A small but adequate bathroom.
2. FAce painting was awesome. Every afternoon they had face painting. FREE. We left a tip...but this was as good or better than what I saw in the parks...and I bet it cost $15 in the parks. Our girls had flowers and vines all over their faces. One was a ladybug. Not a typical 2" rainbow from a kid program at your school.
3. LOCATION. It was very close to the entry of WDW It was CLOSER than the ALL STARS to magic kingdom. It took us 20 minutes from our hotel room to park entry (thant included the tram and ferry!) Of course this would be longer during peak times. Still a great off-site hotel that gets you close do WDW.
4. The pool. Simply awesome then and they weren't done. Lots of free activities. More things you can pay a resort fee for..miniture gold supervised craft activities, floats,etc.)
We did not take advantage of the Character meals (they hadn't started yet.) But Dora is as exciting as Mickey to my kids (hey, I'm a disney fan too, but the kids love Dora.) None of the moderate resorts in Disney offer Character Breakfasts! We did not get the FREE family photo. We did not like to free entertainment.
Comparble in price to getting two rooms at all-stars. But it's really nice to have a couch and three tvs. (you only get one bathroom though.)
I really hope this helps. This was our first trip to Disney and we were only there one night. But my VERY PICKY husband reallly liked it and is dissapointed that we're staying in two rooms at POFQ after Christmas. But alas it's the busiest time of year and a family reunion. We're staying on-site.
BY THE WAY...we found the staff to be very Disney-like. They know they are in competition with CM and were very concerned with guest service. We had excellent staff contact.
I think it's worth the $150/night if you like suite hotels. Especailly if you can get a free breakfast or something thrown in.
Good luck in your decision. I for one think you'll be content with any decision you make as long as you've got a plan for how to get to the parks and what you want to accomplish while you're there!