Momof4girls said:
And for those whose kids want to eat steak and lobster, fabulous - just upgrade them. Or pay out of pocket for that one meal. Are you eating at Coral Reef every day for dinner? Can your kid get by with a dining plan kids' meal and paying a la cart for the lobster bisque on top of it. Is it REALLY going to ruin their vacation - or "take away from the magic" just because they had to eat <gasp> healthy food at ONE restaurant?
Again, then maybe you should eat somewhere else.
Since I mentioned, steak,
fish (adults don't even get lobster as a choice), and lobster soup, I take it this is directed at me(if not entirely, at least in part), so here's my response.
My parents are paying for this trip, and did offer to upgrade DD8 even BEFORE the new menus came out. With a 7 day ticket already on our reservations, the upgrade was something like $220. Most of our meals are buffets, so it is not worth upgrading. Plus, portions on the adult plan are way too much for me, let alone DD. Yes, if DD can't have lobster soup, they will pay OOP for her to have it, but they shouldn't have to. And she really doesn't need an adult portion, but the way the new kid's menu is set up, I doubt they'll offer a kid's portion.
I never said I had a problem with the healthy choices, in fact I said DD wouldn't have any problem with them. She'll eat things like mac & cheese, chicken nuggets, etc, but much prefers a meal that has meat, side, and veggie - thus the reason she was looking forward to the fish at Coral Reef. She's a very good eater, in variety and in quantity - And no, she's not overweight. Sweets are a rare treat at home, so a special dessert at wdw is something she looks forward to. It's still unclear as to whether those desserts will still be available to purchase OOP. I definitely never said anything about it ruining our vacation (so maybe those comments are directed elsewhere).
As far as eating somewhere else, Coral Reef is our CP restaurant, and I'm pretty sure it would not be easy to change if we wanted to (which we don't - it's one of our favorites.)
I knew all along that menus were subject to change, but IMO kid's should still be allowed the option of items that the restaurant is known for. We chose WCC because we want to try the skillet. If DD isn't allowed to have the skillet, there's no way that we're going to order it and eat it in front of her. If I get enough notice that the kid's are not allowed to have the skillet, I will try to change the ADR, but I don't think that it will be very easy.