Not to be a downer, but I read this thread to see what I've been missing! My son and I adore the atmosphere, so we've tried several locations (including the one in Niagara Falls) and always seem to bottom out with our order.
What we've had that was quite poor quality--
Clam Chowder
Appetizer Platter (surprised to see all the plugs for this one--I was really looking forward to the dip, and was disappointed with the flavor, as well as pretty much everything else on it)
Didn't care for the quesadillas much
Hamburger (this was in Niagara--they may have given me the vegetarian patty by mistake, but my supposed real ground beef tasted artificial, like soybean patties--quite disappointing--dry as well and fries were plain tasting)
Key Lime Pie dessert--quality of a defrosted frozen dessert entree with cool whip topping--not bad tasting, just not really restaurant style
Can't remember what else
I think I had a fish dish once and I felt like it was overpriced at the time--just disappointed, overall
We've tried San Francisco, WDW near Animal Kingdom and Downtown Disney in both Florida and California, Orange county and Niagara Falls
Next time I might try Rasta Pasta since I'm seeing some votes for that one, and I was hoping to try the other type of soup that's newer (it's called the 9 bean or something). I might also look into the China Island salad or another type of salad. We love the animation so much...we'd go again if we could find something worth spending money on. I know I'm sounding picky--and really--I'm not the type of "send it back to the kitchen" type like this sounds. I do like Jazz Kitchen and Blue Bayou, so I might like more upscale fare--but I'd love to find a way to enjoy Rainforest! Thanks