I will also say the same thing as others have said, they are both excellent options. For me there is no, "that's easy" or "hands down" or "no doubt about its," between the two. While each is completely different, they are both located in beautiful and breathtaking resorts, they both offer quiet dining rooms, they both offer very good service, and they both offer very good to excellent food. My advice, choose the menu that has the most appeal to you and enjoy; either way you cannot go wrong. Both Jiko and AP are always must do's for us and will be this June for us.