I would love to hear (read) what you thought of YC, WL and CBR!
I loved them all equally, but differently (just like children, lol).
I have to evaluate each resort 2 ways - with kids and without. I've come to realize that the Deluxes will be for when DH and I go without kids, and perhaps when the kids are older. Right now, they are not for my kids. The 2 main reasons being:
1. lack of food court/QS options. We use the food court at least once a day when with the kids. There was no food court at all at YC (had to walk over to BC and it was more like a store with 1 food counter in it, and we only had breakfast there so i'm not sure what the offerings were for lunch or dinner). And Roaring Fork at WC was tiny, only 2 windows. Again, we only did breakfast there so not sure what lunch or dinner was like, and we were there early for breakfast (like 6:30-7:00 a.m.) so I can't imagine how crowded it must get in there at peak times.
2. Pools. The pools at the Mods are much more fun for kids. Exception being Stormalong Bay obviously at BC/YC. My kids would have been underwhelmed at the WL pool. The pools at CBR and AoA were WAY more fun for them.
So those are the 2 negatives for me for YC and WL, but only if I had gone with the kids, which I did not, so it worked out fine and I still love them both. The pluses:
WL's GORGEOUS lobby, we spent a lot of time there. It is just amazing. The ferry to MK and also FW which we took one night to look around FW. The waterfall, geyser, rocks, etc. All beautiful.
YC's location - being able to walk to EP and walk around to the BWI and boat to HS. Lobby not as spectacular as WL but still nice. Lazy River, pool, etc. obviously!
Both have nice restaurants. Loved Whispering Canyon and enjoyed Captain's Grille.
CBR - loved it. I booked preferred and was in Martinique 25 I believe (rusty memory) so no issues with being far away. ODS had a blast in the pool, very fun. Nice big food court, lots of different options, loved that. Loved the colorful decor all around as I love all things Caribbean (not crazy about new interior decor, looks much more somber). Loved being able to sit out on the deck by the water and eat (picnic benches). We had a great experience with the buses. I swear every single time we walked out to the bus stop, our bus was JUST pulling up. Stopping at the other CBR stops was a non-issue. I don't even know if we were the first or last stop, it was such a non-issue that I didn't even notice. i feel like we were always out of CBR pretty quickly so maybe we were the last stop?? I had much more of a problem with the WL buses since we had to go over to FW or GF to pick up, and then sometimes stopped at the water parks? That was a huge PITA, I felt like we were on the buses FOREVER.
I think as far as the "disney feel", AoA is mine and the kids' favorite!