We had Matthew as our KTTK guide in Oct 2005-- in fact, it was the Sunday morning tour on the day Wilma hit.
He was great! We had a very intimate tour, with only 8 people. He had so much information, and you could tell he genuinely loved Disney and his job! It takes a lot of energy to give that tour over and over again!
Clearly, he would have been a more sincere Prince Charming than the one who told me "I like your pants" when we were at the 1900 Park Fare dinner! (even with his crooked teeth!)
After going on the tour with Matthew, it set high expectations for other tours! We're ready to hit some more tours at the other parks!
After that tour, we would evaluate all the different things going on for Safety, Courtesy, Show, Efficiency.
(As a side note-- the way they dealt with Wilma that night at Fantasmic failed miserably in all 4 categories!)
I highly recommend this tour, especially with Matthew! It's worth calling ahead to find out which tour he'll be giving!