Here's the thing: I've been to Tony's several times over the years with mixed results. I always knew it wouldn't be great, but it was always passable. We went once in 2013 (I think) and it was actually fairly decent considering past experiences. Then we went in 2016 just before MNSSHP and... it was shocking. I was raised Italian (as in 2 generations removed), but I am fine with something like Olive Garden or a food court pizza place if the situation calls for it. But what we were given at Tony's was unbelievable. I won't go into details, but we actually went to Pecos Bill's less than 2 hours later, after spending well over $100 at Tony's, just to give you an idea of how much we actually ate. I'm not one to let things go easily, but this experience was so shocking that I couldn't even face complaining because obviously this was not an anomaly if you read other recent reviews. (Disclaimer: Stepson is mentally handicapped and will eat ANYTHING to the point where it's dangerous. It's very difficult to get food away from him once it's set in front of him so that was part of the issue here.)
In fact, I think the best thing to do would be to check out the DIS unplugged review. As a fairly opinionated person, I generally differ in some way, but this could not be any more accurate and I certainly could not have described it any better.
EDIT: I hadn't seen that in a while (unfortunately didn't see it before our last trip,) and just watched it again now. Note the extent the guys go to and how hard they try to be fair. Trust me, they're really, really going above and beyond.
Start at around
48:33 :